Exploring public and private options for the Canadian health consumer.

Conflicting Medical Advice?  Here’s What You Need to Do

  • R. Elan Eisen

    • When faced with a new health issue or a change to an existing one, it’s not uncommon for patients to receive inconsistent or conflicting medical advice from different healthcare providers. Sometimes, it’s a case of feeling strongly that you’d rather not pursue the advice you’re getting. This can lead to confusion, frustration, and anxiety, especially when you’re also dealing with the physical impact of the health issue itself.   

    This type of scenario can often erode trust in the healthcare system and make it harder for patients to make informed decisions about their care. However, there are strategies to navigate these conflicting opinions effectively, ensuring that you get the best possible care for your health needs.

    Step 1: Stay Calm and Gather Information

    When faced with conflicting medical advice, your first reaction might be to panic or feel overwhelmed. However, it’s important to stay calm and approach the situation with a level head. Remember that medicine is both a science and an art; different doctors may have different approaches or interpretations of the same symptoms or test results.

    Start by gathering as much information as possible. This includes:

    In Canada, you absolutely have the right to request copies of your medical records from your healthcare providers or their authorized storage agent, and they are obligated to provide them under the Personal Health Information Protection Act (PHIPA) in Ontario or similar privacy legislation in other provinces.

    Step 2: Communicate Clearly with Your Healthcare Providers

    One of the most common reasons for conflicting medical advice is miscommunication or incomplete information. Make sure that each healthcare provider you see has access to your complete medical history, including past diagnoses, treatments, and any other advice you’ve received. This will help them make more informed recommendations.

    When speaking with your doctor, ask specific questions to better understand their reasoning:

    Being clear, direct, and assertive in your communication can help ensure that your healthcare provider takes the time to explain their reasoning thoroughly.

    Step 3: Seek a Second (or Third) Opinion

    If the conflicting advice is significant or involves major medical decisions (e.g., surgery, long-term medication), it’s wise to seek a second or even third opinion. Ideally, choose a specialist or doctor who is independent and not associated with the same medical practice or hospital system as your current provider. This helps ensure that the second opinion is unbiased and based on fresh, independent judgment.

    When seeking a second opinion:

    In cases of a serious diagnosis or illness, your family doctor should understand that you want to investigate more options.  If you can do your own research for another specialist with a solid reputation, you can ask your doctor for a referral to that specific specialist.  Be sure to present your argument calmly, intelligently and respectfully, bearing in mind that many doctors are inundated with patients who may be taking up excessive time and resources for reasons that the doctor believes are frivolous and time-wasting.

    Step 4: Research and Educate Yourself

    While doctors are the experts in medical science, you are the expert on your own body. Take time to educate yourself about your condition, the proposed treatments, and alternative therapies. There are many reliable resources available, including:

    Be cautious when searching online, as misinformation can spread quickly. Always rely on trusted sources with expertise in healthcare.

    Check out our article on essential support resources for patients and families navigating cancer==>>

    Step 5: Consider a Multidisciplinary Approach

    If you are facing complex or chronic health issues, consider consulting a multidisciplinary team of healthcare providers. This approach involves bringing together specialists from various fields—such as primary care physicians, surgeons, physical therapists, and mental health professionals—to collaborate on your care. By working together, they can provide a more comprehensive and cohesive plan that integrates different viewpoints into one unified strategy.

    Many hospitals and specialty clinics offer this kind of team-based care for conditions like cancer, autoimmune diseases, or neurological disorders, where treatment often requires input from multiple disciplines. Several Canadian hospitals, especially those affiliated with university health networks (e.g., Toronto General Hospital or Vancouver General Hospital), offer this kind of team-based care for conditions like cancer, autoimmune diseases, or neurological disorders, where treatment often requires input from multiple disciplines.

    Step 6: Weigh the Risks and Benefits

    Sometimes, even after seeking multiple opinions and gathering information, you may still receive conflicting advice. In such cases, the next step is to weigh the risks and benefits of each option. This decision process may include:

    If the decision feels overwhelming, don’t hesitate to bring in a trusted family member or friend to help you evaluate the options.

    Step 7: Advocate for Yourself

    As a patient, you are your own best advocate. Don’t be afraid to ask questions, request more information, or challenge advice if it doesn’t feel right for you. Your healthcare providers are there to help you, but they don’t live in your body or understand your experience as well as you do.

    If you’re struggling to advocate for yourself, consider enlisting the help of a professional patient advocate. These trained professionals can help you navigate the healthcare system, facilitate communication between you and your doctors, and ensure that your concerns are being heard and addressed.

    In Canada, patient advocacy is supported by organizations like Patients Canada and Patient Safety Canada. These groups offer resources to help patients understand their rights and navigate the healthcare system more effectively. They can also help facilitate communication between you and your healthcare team if you’re unsure how to proceed.

    Check out our guide to choosing your pharmacist wisely==>>

    Pharmacists laughing

    Step 8: Trust Your Instincts

    At the end of the day, after gathering all the information and opinions, it’s important to trust your own instincts. If something doesn’t feel right, or if you have a strong preference for one treatment over another, listen to yourself. Your intuition, coupled with the knowledge you’ve gained through research and consultation, can be a powerful guide in making the best decisions for your health.

    Receiving conflicting medical advice can be challenging, but it doesn’t have to be overwhelming. By staying calm, gathering information, seeking additional opinions, and advocating for yourself, you can take control of your healthcare journey and make decisions that are right for you.

    Remember, the most important voice in your healthcare decisions is yours. Always trust that, with the right information and support, you can navigate these challenges and achieve the best possible outcome for your health.

    ~ Read more from The Health Insider ~

    The information provided on TheHealthInsider.ca is for educational purposes only and does not substitute for professional medical advice. TheHealthInsider.ca advises consulting a medical professional or healthcare provider when seeking medical advice, diagnoses, or treatment.

    Exit mobile version